Introduction

The college football Heisman Trophy race has entered its final stretch with unexpected twists. Season-ending injuries to two high-profile offensive players have scrambled the betting board and left the award wide open with just three regular-season weeks remaining. While several quarterbacks and one standout receiver have dominated the conversation, new names are now stepping into the spotlight.

What Happened

Miami wide receiver Malachi Toney suffered a high-ankle sprain that is expected to sideline him for the remainder of the regular season. The loss removes one of the nation's most productive pass-catchers and complicates the Heisman case for quarterback Darian Mensah, who had been putting up historic numbers alongside Toney.

Meanwhile, Ohio State's Julian Sayin is out with an injury, pushing backup Luke Fahey into the starting role. Jeremiah Smith, previously viewed as the front-runner, has continued to produce under Fahey, but the Buckeyes have dropped consecutive games, dimming their playoff outlook.

These shifts have moved Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr into the betting lead. According to the latest odds from bet365.com, Carr sits at +140, ahead of Mensah at +280 and Smith at +360. Utah's Devon Dampier (+1500), Oklahoma State's Drew Mestemaker (+1800), and Georgia's Gunner Stockton (+2200) remain in contention.

Why This Matters

Heisman voting often rewards narrative as much as statistics. With Toney unavailable, Mensah must carry Miami's offense alone while trying to secure an ACC title. Smith faces a similar challenge without Sayin and with Ohio State's path to the Big Ten championship uncertain. Carr, on the other hand, has a clear stage with Notre Dame, though the Irish will not play in a conference championship game.

The absence of a clear favorite means late-season performances could decide the trophy. Voters may also weigh head-to-head results, strength of schedule, and whether a candidate's team reaches the College Football Playoff.

Key Takeaways

  • Malachi Toney's ankle injury likely ends his regular season and hurts Darian Mensah's Heisman momentum.
  • Julian Sayin's injury has forced Ohio State to turn to Luke Fahey, coinciding with two straight Buckeyes losses.
  • CJ Carr is the current betting favorite at +140, followed by Mensah (+280) and Jeremiah Smith (+360).
  • Devon Dampier, Drew Mestemaker, and Gunner Stockton offer longer odds but remain viable dark-horse candidates.
  • The Heisman Trophy ceremony is scheduled for Dec. 13, 2025, and will air on ESPN at 8 p.m. ET.

Conclusion

The 2026 Heisman Trophy race is no longer a two- or three-person contest. Injuries have reshaped the landscape, giving Notre Dame's CJ Carr a narrow edge while keeping Miami's Darian Mensah and Ohio State's Jeremiah Smith firmly in the mix. With conference championships and playoff implications still undecided, the next three weeks could produce a dramatic shift in the final ballot. College football fans should watch closely as the contenders chase history before the award is handed out in December.