Introduction

The African Democratic Congress (ADC) has raised serious concerns about the handling of its internal leadership dispute, alleging that the Chief Judge of the Federal High Court acted with bias when the case was moved from one judge to another. The party’s presidential campaign council is demanding the release of the full judgment and has called on Nigeria’s National Judicial Council to investigate the circumstances surrounding the transfer.

What Happened

According to a statement signed by the ADC’s Director of Strategic Communications, Phrank Shaibu, the leadership dispute was originally before Justice Emeka Nwite of the Federal High Court. The case was reassigned to Justice Peter Lifu shortly after the ADC’s National Secretary, Ogbeni Rauf Aregbesola, lodged a formal protest with Chief Judge Justice John Tsoho.

The ADC said Justice Nwite had already begun hearing the matter and had not stepped down. The party’s lawyers had previously opposed the transfer request, describing it as forum shopping and pointing to earlier adjournments. Despite Aregbesola’s written objection on June 2, 2026, the case was assigned to Justice Lifu the following day.

The statement also referenced Justice Lifu’s earlier role in a separate case involving the ADC, in which he reportedly ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission to deregister the party despite an existing Court of Appeal stay. That decision was later nullified, with the appellate court using strong language to describe the conduct.

Why This Matters

The ADC argues that the timing and sequence of the reassignment undermine confidence in a fair hearing. The party notes that Justice Musa Liman had previously dismissed a similar challenge to its leadership, ruling that the internal dispute was non-justiciable and affirming the legitimacy of its recognized national officers. The ADC contends that Justice Lifu should not have disregarded those prior rulings.

Beyond the courtroom, the council framed the dispute as part of a broader political struggle, urging the ruling All Progressives Congress to contest former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar through elections rather than litigation. The ADC reiterated that Atiku remains its presidential candidate and that it will continue defending its position at the Court of Appeal.

Key Takeaways

  • The ADC alleges bias by Federal High Court Chief Judge Justice John Tsoho over the transfer of its leadership case from Justice Emeka Nwite to Justice Peter Lifu.
  • The party says the reassignment occurred one day after its National Secretary, Ogbeni Rauf Aregbesola, formally protested the move.
  • ADC lawyers had opposed the transfer, calling it forum shopping and citing previous adjournments.
  • The council is demanding the full judgment and reasons for the decision, and has asked the National Judicial Council to investigate.
  • The ADC referenced a prior ruling by Justice Musa Liman affirming its leadership and a previous deregistration order by Justice Lifu that was later overturned.
  • The party insists Atiku Abubakar remains its presidential candidate and should be challenged politically, not through the courts.

Conclusion

The ADC’s complaint highlights tensions between political parties and the judiciary over how internal leadership disputes are handled. While the party awaits the full judgment and a possible investigation by the National Judicial Council, the case underscores the importance of transparency in judicial reassignments. For now, the ADC says it will continue to defend its leadership and its presidential candidate through the appropriate legal channels.