Introduction
Amanda Seyfried is stepping into the awards spotlight for her portrayal of disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes in the A24 documentary You Can See Everything. The actress, previously nominated for Mank, says she is ready to campaign for recognition as major voting bodies weigh whether a documentary performance can compete in traditional acting categories.
What Happened
Awards organizations have reached split decisions on Seyfried’s eligibility. The Critics Choice Awards have cleared her for a best supporting actress nomination. By contrast, the Golden Globes, BAFTA, and the SAG Actor Awards have ruled her ineligible. SAG-AFTRA reportedly urged A24 to file an appeal, but insiders indicate the studio will not pursue one and is instead concentrating on an Academy Award bid.
The Academy’s submission deadline has arrived, after which branch executive committees will begin reviewing submissions and announce decisions in early December. A24 has received assurances from representatives of the Academy’s Actors Branch Executive Committee that there is no apparent reason Seyfried would be denied eligibility. Under Academy rules, documentary features can qualify for other categories if they meet requirements, and the Actors Branch has final say on acting eligibility questions. The branch has previously cleared actors in documentaries who received on-screen credits, which Seyfried did for her reenactment work.
Why This Matters
No performance from a documentary has ever received a major awards nomination, and many industry observers questioned whether it was even possible. Seyfried’s case tests the boundaries of how awards bodies define performance in nonfiction filmmaking. You Can See Everything blends traditional documentary techniques with scripted reenactments, placing Seyfried in scenes as Holmes while also appearing as herself to question the filmmakers.
The film’s commercial and critical performance strengthens the argument for recognition. It holds a 96 percent score on Rotten Tomatoes, became only the fourth documentary to lead the domestic box office, has grossed more than $80 million worldwide, and remains in nearly 2,500 theaters. It also swept the Critics Choice Documentary Awards. Directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim have been attending Academy and BAFTA events in the United Kingdom, including a Q&A moderated by Olivia Wilde.
Key Takeaways
- Seyfried is eligible for a Critics Choice best supporting actress nomination for You Can See Everything.
- The Golden Globes, BAFTA, and SAG Actor Awards have deemed her ineligible, and no appeal is expected.
- A24 is focusing on an Oscar campaign and has received positive signals from the Academy’s Actors Branch.
- Seyfried has said she is fully prepared to campaign, calling the experience rare and career-changing.
- The documentary has earned strong reviews, box-office success, and industry attention ahead of December eligibility decisions.
Conclusion
Seyfried told The Hollywood Reporter that she understands the politics and timing of awards season but is willing to put in the work. She described the process as demanding and time-consuming, yet said she is completely ready to put in the effort. While balancing personal priorities after her separation from Thomas Sadoski, she remains committed to supporting the film and encouraging bold storytelling in Hollywood. Whether the Academy ultimately embraces a documentary performance in an acting category remains to be seen, but Seyfried is ready to show up and make the case.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.