Introduction
Stephen Miller, a former senior adviser to President Donald Trump and a leading voice on immigration, founded America First Legal after leaving the White House in 2020. He framed the organization as a conservative counterpart to the ACLU, built to use the court system to advance a MAGA agenda. With Miller now back inside the administration in a top leadership role, the boundary between the legal group and the federal government has grown increasingly thin. A detailed investigation found extensive cooperation between America First Legal and the White House across a significant portion of the group’s lawsuit docket, raising fresh questions about ethics and the proper separation between advocacy organizations and government power.
What Happened
America First Legal was launched in 2021 by Miller and Gene Hamilton, who had helped design the first Trump administration’s family separation policy. The group began with limited resources but quickly expanded, reporting $32 million in donations in 2024. After Trump secured a second term, Miller and several senior AFL lawyers moved into government positions. Miller assumed a top White House advisory role and later became chief of staff. Hamilton served as deputy White House counsel before returning to lead AFL, while Reed Rubinstein joined the State Department as its chief lawyer even though a case he had filed was still active against that agency.
According to the investigation, the administration supported roughly 40 percent of AFL’s cases during Trump’s second term. That support took several forms: filing friend-of-the-court briefs, settling lawsuits that AFL brought against federal agencies, and opening investigations at the group’s request. Notable results include the termination of certain aid to the Palestinian Authority, reversals of school policies on gender identity, the rollback of corporate diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, and legal backing for local sheriffs working with Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
One especially striking example involved an AFL attorney who sued the State Department and later became the agency’s top attorney before the case concluded in AFL’s favor. In another instance, the Justice Department reached a settlement with AFL and Texas’s attorney general on the same day the complaint was filed.
Why This Matters
Legal scholars and ethics watchdogs say the relationship between AFL and the Trump White House exceeds the typical pattern seen under past administrations. While previous presidents have worked with allied outside groups, critics note that AFL rarely, if ever, breaks with the administration’s positions. At the same time, the president declined to sign the conflict-of-interest pledge embraced by every commander in chief since George W. Bush, and he revoked a Biden-era executive order that limited how government employees could handle matters connected to their former or future private-sector work.
Observers warn that when an outside legal organization and the White House operate in close coordination, it can erode public trust in the impartiality of the justice system. Cynthia Brown, a senior ethics counsel at Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, said Americans should be concerned if the new standard is for outside groups and presidential administrations to act as partners in using government resources against organizations they consider opponents.
Key Takeaways
- America First Legal was created by Stephen Miller and Gene Hamilton as a conservative legal alternative to the ACLU.
- Several AFL leaders have held senior roles in the Trump administration, including positions at the White House, State Department, and Justice Department.
- The administration backed approximately 40 percent of AFL’s lawsuits during Trump’s second term.
- Major victories include ending certain Palestinian Authority aid, challenging school gender-identity policies, and rolling back corporate DEI requirements.
- CNN found no proof that formal recusal or lobbying rules were violated, though ethics experts say the arrangement still raises serious concerns.
- AFL maintains that shared political priorities, rather than personal ties, explain the administration’s cooperation.
Conclusion
America First Legal has evolved from an outside agitator into a deeply connected legal force within the Trump movement. Its leaders have moved back and forth between the firm and the federal government, and the administration has frequently supported its courtroom battles. AFL insists its employees followed all applicable ethics rules and that political alignment alone accounts for the collaboration. Still, the pattern documented in the investigation points to an unusually tight integration between an advocacy group and the White House, one that is likely to face continued legal and public scrutiny.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.