Introduction

Baroness Cass, who led the independent review of gender identity services for young people, has told the BBC that she no longer backs the government's current draft bill to ban conversion practices. Speaking on Radio 4's Today programme and before a parliamentary committee, she said while ending these practices is desirable, the legislation as written is not workable and could produce significant unintended fallout.

What Happened

The author of the 2024 Cass review previously voiced support for the draft conversion practices bill when it was introduced in June. She praised its attempt to clearly define what constitutes a conversion practice and what does not. However, after closer examination, she told MPs on the scrutiny committee that she does not support the bill in its current form.

Cass explained that the bill's language could expose parents and healthcare professionals to complaints or even prosecution. She gave the example of a parent who withholds money from a child because they suspect the child might buy a chest binder or hormones, noting that such an action could potentially fall under the law's scope. She also warned that therapists working with gender-distressed young people could face complaints simply because a session left a patient feeling upset, even when the clinical intervention was appropriate.

Why This Matters

The debate comes as the UK moves closer to outlawing conversion practices—interventions intended to change or suppress a person's sexual orientation or gender identity. These practices can occur in religious or family settings and are widely regarded as harmful. The Labour government pledged in its 2024 manifesto to introduce a ban, and the draft bill is currently undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny.

Cass's intervention is significant because her review carries substantial weight in discussions about youth gender care. Her concerns highlight a central tension: how to ban genuinely abusive practices without creating a chilling effect on legitimate therapy or ordinary family decisions. NHS staff at new gender dysphoria clinics have reportedly expressed similar worries about being investigated even if no prosecution follows.

Key Takeaways

  • Baroness Cass no longer supports the current draft conversion practices bill, despite welcoming it initially.
  • She says the bill is not workable and could lead to significant unintended fallout for parents and medical professionals.
  • The legislation defines conversion practices as actions intended to change or suppress sexual orientation or gender identity.
  • Cass warned that therapeutic conversations that distress a young person could be misinterpreted as poor practice under the current wording.
  • She also cited the risk that parents restricting spending on items such as binders or hormones could face investigation.
  • The government says it wants to get the ban right and will consider all evidence from the committee.
  • LGBT organisations including Stonewall and the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy support the bill.

Conclusion

Baroness Cass says she still believes conversion practices are abhorrent and that no LGBT person should be subjected to them. Her objection is not to the principle of a ban, but to the specific wording of the draft legislation. She wants a law that protects vulnerable people without accidentally trapping parents, therapists, or others who are not trying to suppress anyone's identity. With committee hearings ongoing, the government now faces pressure to revise the bill before it becomes law.