Introduction
California’s system for policing educator misconduct is under scrutiny after a former elementary school counselor was criminally charged with abusing 15 students. David Braff is scheduled to stand trial on allegations that he sexually abused children while working in Southern California schools. What makes the case especially troubling is that state regulators received detailed complaints about his conduct in 2019—five years before his arrest—yet allowed him to remain in classrooms and counseling offices. A joint investigation by KQED and ProPublica found that Braff was not an isolated example. The state’s teacher licensing agency repeatedly let educators accused of sexual misconduct keep working until they faced criminal charges, even after school districts had already flagged them for inappropriate behavior.
What Happened
According to school district records and court documents, at least seven students told Santa Paula Unified investigators in 2019 that Braff had touched them inappropriately. Allegations included forcing a child to sit on his lap, rubbing students’ legs, and touching them near their private areas. Braff resigned during the district’s internal review, and the district submitted a 20-page report to the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing. Despite the detailed allegations, the state agency did not suspend Braff’s credentials. He went on to work at three additional schools in Southern California. Prosecutors allege that another student complained about his behavior at one of those later campuses. Braff was arrested in 2024 and has remained in jail since November of that year. He has pleaded not guilty, and his attorney declined to comment.
The investigation also examined two other educators. Brashawn Washington, a middle school math teacher, was reported to the state after sending an 11-year-old student explicit messages and a video showing a boy’s genitals. He resigned, found a new job at Pasadena High School, and continued contacting students through online games. He was eventually arrested and sentenced to more than eight years in prison. Matthew Shelton, a Bay Area elementary teacher, had been acquitted of abuse charges in Napa Valley years earlier and received only a confidential warning from the state. He later taught in Benicia, where new students accused him of inappropriate touching. He was convicted last month and awaits sentencing.
Why This Matters
The pattern points to structural weaknesses in how California disciplines teachers. The Commission on Teacher Credentialing relies on a volunteer panel called the Committee of Credentials to review misconduct cases and recommend punishment. That panel operates without written guidelines defining when discipline is warranted or what penalties should apply. State investigators in several cases did not interview the students who made allegations, instead relying solely on school district reports. Former agency staffers and former committee members told reporters that the volunteer panel sometimes dismissed children’s accounts as unreliable.
When the state does not take disciplinary action, there is no warning flag in the public database of educators. Schools hiring new staff may have no way of knowing that a teacher was forced to resign over misconduct allegations. Victims also suffer lasting harm. One student identified only as J. said she avoided processing the abuse for years, struggled with suicidal thoughts, and has been homeschooled for nearly three years. She still has nightmares about her former counselor.
Key Takeaways
- A former California school counselor faces trial for allegedly abusing 15 students, despite misconduct complaints reaching state regulators in 2019.
- The state’s educator licensing agency allowed Braff to keep working until his 2024 arrest, after which he had already obtained jobs at three more schools.
- Two other teachers profiled in the investigation were similarly permitted to continue teaching until criminal charges were filed.
- California’s credentialing panel lacks written guidelines for disciplining educators accused of misconduct.
- State investigators did not always interview student victims, relying instead on district-led inquiries.
- When no formal discipline is issued, abusive educators can move to new schools without any red flag appearing in public records.
Conclusion
The Braff case and the accompanying investigation reveal a system that often prioritizes the legal rights of accused educators over the immediate safety of students. State officials have acknowledged that a comprehensive review of the educator discipline process is needed, but no timeline for reform has been set. For parents, school administrators, and policymakers, the takeaway is clear: reports of misconduct must trigger swift, independent action—not years of delay while children remain in classrooms with adults under suspicion. Until California closes these oversight gaps, students will continue to bear the cost of inaction.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.