Introduction

The European Union is pushing forward with digital identity wallets designed to let citizens store and share credentials like driver’s licenses, diplomas, and banking details from a smartphone. While the system is built around selective disclosure—showing only the information a service actually needs—privacy researchers warn that the current design may still create a paper trail. Cryptographic markers left behind during verification could allow different organizations to recognize the same person across unrelated services, undermining the promise of anonymity.

What Happened

Under the European Digital Identity Regulation, adopted in 2024, EU member states are racing to launch interoperable wallets before a year-end deadline. Germany’s version was unveiled in September 2026 by Federal Minister for Digitalization Karsten Wildberger. The regulation already requires selective disclosure, so a venue checking age can receive confirmation that someone is over 18 without learning their name or address. However, when a verifier scans a credential, it still logs digital signatures and identifiers needed to validate the document. According to cryptographers interviewed by IEEE Spectrum, two separate verifiers could compare those records and determine they dealt with the same individual. That conflicts with the regulation’s unlinkability principle, which states that tracking users through digital attestations should not be possible.

One proposed fix involves issuing multiple versions of each credential, each carrying different cryptographic data, so the wallet presents a fresh certificate every time. But researchers note that if the government issuer can connect those versions to the original recipient, the link can still be reconstructed.

Why This Matters

The debate centers on zero-knowledge proofs, a cryptographic method that lets someone prove a statement is true—such as holding a valid government ID—without exposing the underlying data or creating a reusable record of the interaction. These proofs have existed since the 1980s, but only recently became practical for smartphones. A Google research team demonstrated a way to generate them using credentials signed with elliptic-curve cryptography, making them viable for wallet apps.

Despite this, the European Commission has not made zero-knowledge proofs mandatory for the first wallet rollout. Officials cite the lack of a clear, certifiable standard agreed upon across the EU and say more consultation is needed with bodies such as the European Cybersecurity Certification Group. The Commission describes the technology as a “core road map item” rather than a day-one requirement. Cryptographers are divided: some argue the law should mandate the proofs now to prevent downgrade attacks where service providers fall back to older, traceable verification; others say the wallets should launch immediately and improve in a second generation, since delaying could lock in infrastructure that is hard to change later.

Key Takeaways

  • EU digital identity wallets are rolling out across member states under a 2024 regulation, with Germany launching its version in September 2026.
  • Verification records can include digital signatures and identifiers that may allow different services to link activity to the same user.
  • Zero-knowledge proofs could prevent this cross-service tracking, but they are not yet required by EU law.
  • The European Commission calls zero-knowledge proofs a future road-map item and wants more pan-European consultation before mandating them.
  • Privacy experts disagree on whether to delay the rollout until stronger cryptography is in place or proceed now and upgrade later.

Conclusion

Europe’s digital wallet project stands at a crossroads. The technology to make these credentials genuinely unlinkable already exists, but policymakers have chosen not to require it from the start. Whether that caution preserves flexibility or bakes in long-term surveillance risks may depend on how quickly a second generation of wallets arrives—and whether users are compelled to upgrade. For now, millions of Europeans are set to receive digital IDs that promise privacy in principle, even if the cryptographic foundation to guarantee it remains optional.