Introduction
A public disagreement between Washington and two of its closest European allies has erupted over how Ukraine should conduct its war against Russia. Germany and the United Kingdom are pushing back against U.S. objections to Kyiv’s long-range strikes inside Russian territory, setting the stage for a strained atmosphere just before President Donald Trump is scheduled to sit down with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping.
What Happened
At a NATO meeting in Brussels, U.S. Under Secretary of Defense Elbridge Colby argued that Ukraine’s deep-strike campaign has not brought the war closer to an end and has not stopped Russian forces from advancing on the front lines. He specifically questioned attacks on what he described as civilian infrastructure, pointing to Russian e-commerce firm Wildberries as an example, and suggested such strikes may have strengthened public support for the Kremlin.
Colby did acknowledge that Ukraine’s use of drones and other new tactics against Russian front-line positions has been effective, and he noted that Ukrainian forces captured more territory than Russia in October for the second month running.
German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius responded sharply, calling criticism of strikes aimed at legitimate military targets in Russia “quite a stupid thing.” He redirected attention toward Russian attacks on Ukraine’s civilian energy, water, and heating systems, which he described as terrorism. British Defence Secretary Wes Streeting backed that view, stating that allies should not dictate how Ukraine fights and arguing that the strikes have degraded Russia’s war machine while saving lives.
The timing is significant. Ukraine has intensified attacks on Russian oil facilities, logistics hubs, and military sites in recent months. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy recently praised an operation against the Kerch Bridge, the key link between Russia and occupied Crimea, saying it dealt a symbolic blow to Moscow. Russian officials said the bridge was damaged but would be rebuilt.
Why This Matters
The split exposes a genuine divide in Western strategy. While the U.S. appears concerned that long-range attacks could provoke further escalation or distract from battlefield priorities, Berlin and London see the strikes as a legitimate way to raise the cost of aggression for Moscow. The disagreement comes at a delicate moment, with Trump, Putin, and Xi expected to discuss trade, artificial intelligence, nuclear weapons, and the war in Ukraine during a trilateral meeting on the sidelines of an Asia-Pacific economic forum in Shenzhen.
Key Takeaways
- Germany and the United Kingdom publicly rejected U.S. criticism of Ukraine’s deep strikes inside Russia.
- U.S. official Elbridge Colby said the strikes have not ended the war or slowed Russia’s advance, though he praised Ukraine’s front-line drone tactics.
- British and German defense leaders argued the attacks degrade Russia’s military capacity and are not for outside powers to second-guess.
- The dispute unfolds just before a planned Trump-Putin-Xi meeting in Shenzhen, China.
- Ukraine recently targeted the Kerch Bridge and Russian oil infrastructure as part of its expanded strike campaign.
Conclusion
As Washington, London, and Berlin sort out their differences, Ukraine continues to press its long-range campaign against Russian targets. Whether the upcoming summit produces any shift in Western policy remains uncertain, but the current rift makes clear that allied unity on Ukraine’s military tactics is no longer automatic.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.