Introduction

A recent investigation revealed that a data-driven election tool produced false death records for several registered voters in Forsyth County, Georgia. Despite the errors, a local election board member used the information to push for challenges against their ballots. All four individuals flagged as deceased were later confirmed to be alive, and the county board dismissed the attempts to remove their votes.

What Happened

In the weeks following the midterm elections, Max Clavijo, a Republican member of the Forsyth County election board, shared documents with fellow officials and the county’s election director. The materials, drawn from a software program called ELLY’s Election Monitor, questioned the validity of more than 22,000 voter registrations and specifically disputed the eligibility of 69 people.

Among those 69, Clavijo asserted that four voters had died. He submitted obituaries as supporting evidence, though the documents contained inconsistencies. For example, one obituary indicated the deceased lived in Arizona, making it impossible for that person to cast a ballot in Forsyth County.

ProPublica reporters contacted the four voters and confirmed that each was alive. Alexis Ramirez, a nurse who works night shifts, said she voted during early voting and was stunned to learn her ballot had been challenged. Saramma George described feeling angry that her voting status was questioned. Chris Strickland told reporters plainly that he was alive and present. A third voter’s son confirmed his mother was living but declined to speak publicly.

The board ultimately rejected the challenges. During the meeting, Clavijo acknowledged he could not guarantee the data was completely accurate, and the cover letter accompanying the submission noted the information had not undergone human review.

Why This Matters

The episode illustrates how unverified data can be weaponized against eligible voters. ELLY aggregates public records from sources such as voter files, change-of-address filings, tax documents, obituaries, and real estate listings, but it does not include personal identifiers like Social Security numbers, driver’s license numbers, or full birth dates. That limitation raises the risk of false matches, especially when people share similar names.

Voting rights advocates have labeled the tool error-prone. In Cherokee County, the local election director complained to the state board after the system incorrectly listed a board member’s spouse as deceased. Critics argue that tools like ELLY, promoted by groups tied to election denial networks, can create unnecessary barriers and cast doubt on legitimate votes without sufficient proof.

The tool was developed by Rick Richards, a member of the Election Integrity Network led by conservative attorney Cleta Mitchell. Mitchell has been associated with efforts to challenge the 2020 presidential election and has advocated for tighter voting rules. Richards has defended ELLY’s reliability, dismissing accuracy concerns as “horse hockey,” while placing responsibility for verification on local election workers.

Key Takeaways

  • A Forsyth County election board member used data from ELLY’s Election Monitor to challenge 69 voter registrations, including four people he claimed were dead.
  • ProPublica confirmed all four voters were alive, and the board rejected the challenges.
  • The tool lacks key personal identifiers, increasing the chance of mismatches involving voters with common or similar names.
  • One obituary submitted as evidence listed a residence outside Georgia, contradicting the claim that the person voted in Forsyth County.
  • Board members criticized the process, noting that challenges lacked proper verification and bypassed formal procedures.
  • The effort is connected to a broader network of conservative activists seeking to contest election results and scrutinize voter rolls.

Conclusion

The Forsyth County case serves as a cautionary example of what can happen when election officials rely on incomplete data without independent verification. While maintaining accurate voter rolls is a legitimate goal, the process must include safeguards to protect eligible voters from erroneous challenges. For the four Georgians caught up in this dispute, the episode ended with their ballots intact—but it also highlighted the ongoing pressure on local election systems from partisan data tools and activism.