Introduction
A photojournalist’s job often ends when the news cycle moves on, but some stories demand a return. Eight years after photographing two parents at their sentencing in an Oregon courtroom, Beth Nakamura of The Oregonian picked up her camera again to document the life of the child who survived.
What Happened
In 2017, Sarah and Travis Mitchell, members of the Followers of Christ faith-healing community near Portland, Oregon, had premature twins. Their beliefs prohibit medical treatment, so when both infants struggled to breathe, the couple prayed instead of going to a hospital. One twin, Ginnifer, died after four hours. Law enforcement eventually became involved at the family’s home, and Evelyn, the surviving twin, was taken for medical care.
The Mitchells pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide for Ginnifer’s death and to criminal mistreatment for not seeking care for Evelyn. They were sentenced to more than six years in prison. Evelyn, only days old at the time, was placed in the permanent custody of Marshall and Jennifer Phillips, another couple from the same religious group.
Years later, Nakamura began photographing Evelyn and the Phillipses as the girl grew up. The project, a collaboration between ProPublica and The Oregonian, captures Evelyn at age nine and contrasts Oregon’s approach to faith-healing exemptions with Idaho’s, where similar religious protections have been tied to preventable child deaths.
Why This Matters
The case highlights the conflict between religious freedom and the state’s duty to protect children. Oregon has adjusted its laws to allow greater intervention, while Idaho’s broad exemptions continue to limit authorities’ ability to act. ProPublica’s investigation found 15 recent deaths among children in Idaho’s Followers of Christ community that experts believe could have been prevented with medical care.
For Evelyn, routine doctor visits are now a normal part of childhood, but each appointment carries a deeper meaning given her early survival. Her story places a human face on the broader debate over faith-based medical exemptions.
Key Takeaways
- Travis and Sarah Mitchell received prison sentences exceeding six years after their infant daughter died without medical intervention.
- Evelyn, the surviving twin, was placed in the care of Marshall and Jennifer Phillips shortly after birth.
- Beth Nakamura documented Evelyn’s life eight years after covering the original sentencing.
- The reporting examines differences between Oregon and Idaho laws on faith-healing exemptions and child protection.
- ProPublica identified 15 recent preventable child deaths connected to the Followers of Christ sect in Idaho.
Conclusion
From baptism preparations to birthday meals and father-daughter dances, Nakamura’s photographs show a child thriving in a home where medical care is routine. The project is a rare opportunity for a journalist to revisit a subject years later and witness what happens next. Evelyn’s life stands as a reminder that behind every legal case is a continuing story shaped by decisions made in the earliest hours.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.