Introduction

For more than two decades, I’ve known Joe Vanella. To me, he’s the guy who helped me move into Brooklyn, the fantasy baseball commissioner I’ve competed against for years, and a proud Long Islander with a massive laugh and an even bigger heart. To the rest of the world, he’s suddenly a breakout star on NBC and Peacock’s The Traitors: New Blood, where he played the role of a Traitor inside a Scottish castle. Watching a close friend become a reality television phenomenon is strange, funny, and occasionally surreal—especially when that friend is a funeral director who now gets stopped for photos while working.

What Happened

Joe Vanella entered the latest season of The Traitors: New Blood as a civilian contestant. Unlike many cast members, he had no influencer background or social media following. He’s a funeral director from Long Island, married to Meg, with three young children. He was cast as one of the “traitors,” meaning his job was to deceive the other players while avoiding detection. The show is hosted by Alan Cumming and filmed in a castle in the Scottish Highlands.

Viewers quickly latched onto Joe. He winked at the camera in the premiere, became the subject of countless memes, and inspired Halloween costumes. One of the most talked-about moments involved him tossing an apple to another player—a move fans dubbed "Fruitgate"—and later defending his apple obsession by repeatedly saying the word "roughage." He also wore a black button-down shirt with pink flamingos and chocolate-colored khakis to his casting interview, and he brought his own wardrobe to Scotland, including plenty of Hawaiian shirts.

Outside the game, Joe shared a meaningful moment with fellow contestant Michael, offering support at the round table. Michael later told Joe that he meant a lot as a gay man who hadn’t always felt supported by people who looked and sounded like Joe. The two remain close friends.

Since returning home, Joe has been recognized at funeral homes, in Penn Station, and while trick-or-treating with his kids. His wife, Meg, supported his decision to go to Scotland and wanted to be surprised by the outcome when he returned.

Why This Matters

Joe’s story illustrates how quickly ordinary people can become public figures through reality television. He wasn’t seeking fame; he wanted to visit the castle, meet the host, and be on his favorite show. Yet within weeks, strangers knew his face, his catchphrases, and even his apple preferences. For someone in a profession built around privacy and solemnity—funeral directing—that collision of public and private life is especially striking.

It also highlights the social dynamics of shows like The Traitors. Joe succeeded not through physical challenges—he admits his cardio is lacking—but through relationships, humor, and reading the room. His experience shows that reality TV fame can be fleeting but deeply personal, affecting family, work, and how strangers perceive you.

Key Takeaways

  • Joe Vanella is a Long Island funeral director and father of three who appeared as a Traitor on The Traitors: New Blood.
  • He had no prior influencer experience and joined the show because he was a fan, not because he wanted fame.
  • Viewers made him a meme sensation, particularly for an apple-throwing moment and his repeated use of the word “roughage.”
  • He has been recognized in public and even at funeral homes since the season aired.
  • His wife supported his appearance and asked to be surprised by the results when he came home.

Conclusion

More than a month after his time in the Scottish castle, Joe Vanella is still adjusting to being “that guy from The Traitors.” He’s eating more apples—though he claims he’s tired of them—fielding recognition from strangers, and trying to make sure people walk away with a good impression of him. For his friends, it’s a reminder that the people we know in everyday life can suddenly become part of the cultural conversation. For Joe, it’s been a wild ride that started with a casting tape and a pair of casket-themed sneakers that never left the closet.