Introduction

You know the figure. It has been on your mind for months. Perhaps it is a product line that has missed its targets for six straight quarters. Perhaps it is a second location in a city that never gained traction. Perhaps it is a key hire everyone else has stopped supporting, or a flagship client who costs more to serve than the relationship generates. You have done the math on a napkin, then set the napkin aside and told yourself the approach still works—it just needs more runway. That is the sunk cost fallacy in action, and here is the deceptive part: it does not feel like an error. It feels like conviction.

Matthew Ferry coaches high-performing professionals, and his most difficult conversation with clients is rarely about what to begin. It is about what to stop. Below is a look at the research, where the science stands, and a practical process for leaving a position you have defended for too long.

What Happened

In 1985, psychologists Hal Arkes and Catherine Blumer published a widely cited study titled "The Psychology of Sunk Cost." Working at a university theater box office, they sold 54 season ticket holders the same subscription at three different prices: full price, a small discount, and a larger discount. Then they tracked attendance. Across the first five performances, people who paid full price used an average of 4.11 tickets, while the discounted groups used roughly 3.32 and 3.29. The plays were identical. The only variable was how much money had already been spent, and it influenced whether people showed up.

The study produced two findings that should catch any business owner's attention. First, people who had already invested in a project tended to view that same project as more likely to succeed than people who had not invested. Spending money can reshape what you believe is probable. Second, the bias persisted even among people who had studied economics. Knowing the concept by name offered no measurable protection.

A 2025 paper in Brain Sciences later questioned the reliability of written survey scenarios used to measure sunk cost thinking. That criticism is worth noting, but it does not undermine the original theater experiment, which involved real people spending their own money and making real attendance decisions.

Why This Matters

This is not a problem you can read your way out of. Beneath the surface is an early-learned rule: never waste what you have already paid for. Abandoning a project feels like personally authorizing a loss, so the mind holds the position and quietly inflates the forecast to justify staying.

Ferry says the warning sign is often calmness. The leaders he works with are not confused or uninformed; they usually know more about the situation than anyone else. The red flag is that they have stopped evaluating the position and started representing it. They have become its attorney. An evaluator collects information to make a decision. An attorney collects information to defend a decision already made.

From the inside, this feels steady, not panicked. It looks like conviction from the outside. A useful language test is to listen to your private justification. If it sounds like "the approach still works, the timing was early, just give it two more quarters," nobody in that sentence is actually deciding anything. Someone is defending money already spent.

Key Takeaways

  • A sunk cost is money that is gone whether you continue or quit. It should not factor into future decisions.
  • Past investment can distort your judgment about the likelihood of future success.
  • Understanding the sunk cost fallacy does not make you immune to it.
  • If you are defending a position rather than evaluating it objectively, you may be trapped by the bias.
  • Ask the zero-based question: knowing what you know now, would you enter this position at today's price?
  • Spend one hour arguing the case for exit as if you were hired to make that argument.
  • Hand the final decision to a partner, board member, or adviser who was not involved in the original commitment.
  • Set tripwires for new commitments: define the result and date that will trigger an automatic review.

Conclusion

Courage is not the missing ingredient. A reliable process is. The next time you are tempted to hold on because of what you have already committed, revisit those figures and view them through an investor's lens rather than an attorney's brief. The money is already gone. The only question is whether you will keep paying to protect a forecast that exists only in your head.

Matthew Ferry is the Lead Instructor of SUCCESS Coaching Certification™, a spiritual teacher, master coach, and bestselling author. Since 1993, he has helped high-performing professionals, entrepreneurs, and executives pursue what he calls Enlightened Prosperity™. He is the author of Quiet Mind Epic Life, creator of the Mental Journey To Millions, and a two-time TEDx speaker.