Introduction

A federal safety net created to protect civilian employees working for U.S. military contractors in war zones has quietly funneled nearly $5 billion to private insurance companies over the last decade. While the program was designed to cover medical care and lost wages for people injured or killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, government records and internal memos show it has also become a vehicle for questionable billing, weak oversight, and potential fraud. Even officials inside the Department of Labor have described the arrangement as vulnerable to abuse and profit-driven manipulation.

What Happened

Under the Defense Base Act and the War Hazards Compensation Act, the government reimburses insurers when contractor injuries are linked to hostilities rather than ordinary workplace accidents. The government also adds a handling fee of up to 15 percent. Since 2014, four carriers — AIG, CNA Financial, Starr Insurance, and Allied World — have collected the bulk of these payments, with AIG alone receiving more than $1 billion. None of the companies has been accused of wrongdoing.

The investigation found that insurers sometimes deny legitimate claims for years, then reverse course and tell the Labor Department the same injuries were war-related, unlocking full reimbursement plus legal and administrative costs. In one case, a cook from Kosovo who developed PTSD after working at Bagram Airfield saw her claim challenged for nearly two years. After the insurer settled, it successfully billed the government for more than $269,000, including fees for lawyers, doctors, and a private investigator who surveilled her overseas.

A 2018 policy change made it easier to approve PTSD claims without tying them to a specific incident. Reimbursements to insurers subsequently surged, reaching nearly $1 billion by September 2026. By 2024, about 88 percent of all war-hazard reimbursements involved psychological injuries.

Why This Matters

Taxpayers are footing the bill for a system that the Labor Department has struggled to police for years. Internal reviews describe outdated computer systems, a lack of enforcement staff, and an inability to issue fines. One former official estimated that $100 million to $150 million in annual payments could be lost to waste, overbilling, or improper claims. Because the program operates largely out of public view, there is little pressure to reform it, even as conflicts wind down and claims continue to arrive from workers in countries such as Uganda and the Philippines.

The arrangement also affects the government's ability to recruit civilian workers for dangerous assignments. If contractors cannot trust that injuries will be covered, they may demand higher pay or refuse to deploy — a dynamic that could complicate future military operations that rely on non-combat personnel.

Key Takeaways

  • Taxpayers have paid insurers nearly $5 billion over the past decade through the Defense Base Act and War Hazards Compensation Act.
  • A 2018 rule change loosened PTSD documentation standards, after which war-hazard reimbursements tripled to nearly $1 billion.
  • Four insurers — AIG, CNA Financial, Starr Insurance, and Allied World — have received the majority of payments since 2014.
  • Government memos acknowledge weak safeguards, with one former official estimating up to $150 million in annual losses to fraud or abuse.
  • Insurers are allowed to dispute a claim and later seek government reimbursement by classifying the same injury as war-related.

Conclusion

The program was born out of lessons from World War II, when civilian contractors on Wake Island were captured and killed by enemy forces. Congress created the Defense Base Act to ensure companies buying insurance for overseas workers would not bear the full risk of combat injuries. Decades later, that same structure has produced billions in government payouts to private carriers, with minimal oversight and no clear mechanism to stop abuse.

Reform efforts have stalled repeatedly. A push to have the government self-insure injured workers — a model used for federal employees — died in Congress more than a decade ago. As the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan recede from headlines, the long tail of claims continues, meaning payments could persist for years. Without stronger controls, experts warn, taxpayers will keep subsidizing a system that rewards insurers regardless of whether they deny or approve the claims of the workers it was meant to protect.