Introduction

Ten years after newsrooms invested heavily in a video push that failed to deliver, the media industry is trying again. This time, the motivation isn't coming from a single platform's promise. It comes from audience behavior: people are watching short, vertical clips on TikTok, Reels, and Shorts, and they increasingly expect longer, TV-style programming on the same apps. Publishers that once treated social video as optional now see it as necessary to remain relevant.

What Happened

The original pivot-to-video in the mid-2010s ended poorly for many outlets. Publishers hired video staff and leaned heavily on Facebook, only to learn that the platform had overstated how many people were actually watching. When the anticipated revenue never arrived, newsrooms cut jobs and shut down video operations.

The current wave is broader but carries similar pressure. TikTok helped make vertical video mainstream during the pandemic, and short-form clips now appear everywhere from LinkedIn to YouTube. Pew Research found that one in five Americans regularly gets news from TikTok, a figure that rises to nearly 40 percent among adults under 30. Nielsen data places YouTube's share of television viewing at roughly 16 percent.

Some publishers have already adjusted. The Washington Post built an early TikTok audience before many competitors joined the platform. CNN has experimented with debate-style formats popularized by independent creators, while The New York Times launched a casual vertical video series meant to feel like a call from a friend. Other outlets are partnering with influencers through creator networks, and reporters are turning investigations and podcasts into short vertical clips.

Yet the landscape is shifting once more. Platforms are moving beyond short clips toward longer, higher-production programming designed for television screens. YouTube is courting creators for exclusive shows, Instagram has introduced horizontal video uploads up to 90 minutes, and the BBC struck a deal with YouTube for dedicated programming and a 24/7 livestream. Even X is paying select creators to post more video.

Why This Matters

Audiences have moved, and news organizations risk ceding the conversation to independent creators if they do not show up in the same formats. Viewers often trust familiar personalities more than institutional brands, which means a reporter speaking directly to a camera can build a connection that a traditional article might not.

The business model remains uncertain, however. Platforms measure success in views, but a view does not guarantee a subscriber, a reader, or revenue. Publishers learned that lesson during the first video pivot, and many of the same questions remain: Can attention on social media be converted into lasting support? And as platforms demand longer, more expensive content, can newsrooms afford to keep up?

Key Takeaways

  • The first pivot-to-video in the 2010s collapsed after platforms inflated engagement metrics and revenue failed to materialize.
  • Short-form vertical video is now mainstream, with significant portions of the public—especially younger adults—getting news from TikTok and YouTube.
  • Publishers such as The Washington Post, CNN, and The New York Times are testing creator-style formats, influencer partnerships, and vertical video series.
  • Platforms are shifting toward long-form, TV-ready video, which could raise production costs and barriers to entry for news organizations.
  • Views do not automatically equal income, and publishers must balance audience reach with sustainable monetization.

Conclusion

The media industry's relationship with tech platforms has always been a balancing act. Platforms control where audiences spend their time, and publishers must follow or risk becoming invisible. A decade ago, chasing video led to layoffs and broken trust. Today, the tools are cheaper and the audience is larger, but the fundamental risk remains: building a strategy on someone else's platform means playing by someone else's rules.

Whether this second video push succeeds will depend on whether newsrooms can create genuine value for viewers without sacrificing editorial independence—or their bottom line. Short-form video is not disappearing, but the move toward longer, more expensive programming suggests the next phase could demand even more from publishers than the last one did.