Introduction
The U.S. Navy has removed several senior military leaders in recent months without issuing the public announcements that typically accompany such decisions. The quiet personnel changes include the dismissal of an entire submarine command team and the relief of a destroyer commander operating in the Middle East. The silence has triggered concern from lawmakers, who argue the Navy is departing from long-standing transparency norms and complicating congressional oversight.
What Happened
According to reporting from the Associated Press, the Navy removed the commanding officer, executive officer, and senior enlisted leader of the nuclear-powered attack submarine USS South Dakota after the vessel struck an object on the seabed. The service did not notify the House Armed Services Committee about the personnel actions, prompting a formal letter from Reps. Joe Courtney of Connecticut and Adam Smith of Washington.
Separately, the Navy relieved Cmdr. Caitlin Cunningham of command of the USS Michael Murphy on September 27. The destroyer had been deployed to support operations involving Iran. Officials cited a loss of confidence in her leadership, but the Navy did not publicly announce the change even when asked.
In another case, Rear Adm. Dr. Brian Monahan, who served as the attending physician for Congress and the Supreme Court, left his position while a Navy investigation was underway. His departure was not publicly announced or confirmed by the service. Monahan had held the role for nearly 18 years.
The developments come as acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao prepares for a confirmation hearing to become the permanent civilian head of the department.
Why This Matters
The Navy has traditionally informed Congress and the public when it removes commanders and other high-profile officials. By bypassing that practice, the service risks eroding trust with legislative overseers. Courtney and Smith wrote that the lack of communication raises questions about the Navy's commitment to transparency and a productive relationship with Congress. The situation could also complicate Cao's confirmation process next week.
Broader patterns of military secrecy are emerging as well. U.S. Central Command has provided limited information about recent strikes in the Middle East, and satellite imagery providers have delayed releasing photos of the region at the request of U.S. officials. An Associated Press analysis found it took months to confirm that Iranian drone and missile strikes damaged or destroyed structures at 26 military bases and other sites housing American equipment.
Key Takeaways
- The Navy removed the full leadership team of the USS South Dakota following an underwater collision but did not announce the action publicly.
- Cmdr. Caitlin Cunningham was relieved of command of the USS Michael Murphy in late September due to a loss of confidence in her leadership.
- Rear Adm. Dr. Brian Monahan departed his post as attending physician for Congress and the Supreme Court during an ongoing Navy investigation.
- Democratic Reps. Joe Courtney and Adam Smith sent a letter to Navy leadership expressing frustration over the lack of notification.
- The removals coincide with acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao's upcoming confirmation hearing and a wider trend of restricted military information sharing.
Conclusion
For an institution that relies on public trust and congressional support, the decision to keep leadership changes out of the spotlight carries real political and institutional costs. As lawmakers demand answers and Cao moves toward his confirmation vote, the Navy may face pressure to restore its traditional practice of transparency. Whether the service changes course remains to be seen, but the current silence has already sparked a significant oversight confrontation.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.