In March 2017, a newborn girl named Ginnifer died in her father's arms inside a pistachio-green house in Oregon City. Her parents belonged to the Followers of Christ, a closed religious community that rejects modern medicine. Hours later, investigators discovered that Ginnifer had a twin sister, Evelyn, who was still alive but struggling to breathe. What followed was a rare intervention by Oregon authorities that would separate Evelyn from her birth family and place her with a former believer who had already defied the sect once before.

What Happened

Sarah Mitchell went into labor without any prenatal care. Three untrained women assisted with the delivery in her home. When Ginnifer stopped breathing, no one called 911. Her father later told investigators that he did not call because it was in God's hands. He anointed the baby with olive oil and prayed. Ginnifer died four hours after she was born, weighing just three and a half pounds.

Deputy Medical Examiner Eric Tonsfeldt arrived to investigate and sensed something was wrong. While waiting for coffee in the kitchen, one of the baby's grandfathers asked if it would matter that Ginnifer had a twin. Tonsfeldt found Evelyn in a bathroom, being fed with an eyedropper by women from the sect. She was barely conscious.

Police gave the family an ultimatum: take Evelyn to the hospital or officers would take her. She was admitted to a neonatal intensive care unit in Portland with respiratory distress syndrome. After a breathing machine and feeding tube stabilized her, the state moved to protect her. Sarah and Travis Mitchell were eventually charged with murder by neglect and criminal mistreatment. In 2018, they pleaded guilty and received six and a half years in prison—the harshest sentence ever given to parents in the sect.

Meanwhile, Marshall and Jennifer Phillips, lifelong members of the Followers who had once taken their own son to the hospital for Type 1 diabetes, agreed to care for Evelyn. Their decision cost them their community. They were eventually baptized in the Willamette River and left the sect entirely.

Why This Matters

Oregon's approach to faith-healing communities has changed dramatically over the last few decades. Between 1989 and 1999, 18 children connected to the Oregon City Followers died, a mortality rate the state medical examiner estimated at 26 times the general population. Public outrage led lawmakers to remove religious defenses for manslaughter and criminal mistreatment in 1999, and to eliminate the spiritual-treatment defense for any crime in 2011.

Since then, child deaths in the sect have become rare. Ginnifer's death in 2017 was one of the last. The contrast with neighboring Idaho is stark: where Idaho law still shields parents who rely solely on prayer, reporting has documented at least 11 preventable child deaths among Followers families.

The case also shows the limits of state power. Even after Evelyn's birth parents pleaded guilty and signed a statement admitting they should have sought medical care, the message they were ordered to post at their meetinghouse was torn down the same day. Years later, the Mitchells sought to regain guardianship of Evelyn before withdrawing the request. They are now asking for expanded visitation.

Key Takeaways

  • Ginnifer Mitchell died in 2017 after her parents, members of the Followers of Christ, declined medical care following a home birth with no prenatal care.
  • Her twin sister, Evelyn, survived because a medical examiner discovered her and Oregon authorities compelled her parents to seek hospital treatment.
  • Sarah and Travis Mitchell pleaded guilty in 2018 to criminally negligent homicide and criminal mistreatment, receiving the harshest sentence ever imposed on Followers parents in Oregon.
  • Marshall and Jennifer Phillips, former sect members who had previously defied the group to save their own son, became Evelyn's permanent guardians and left the faith.
  • Oregon removed religious defenses for crimes against children in 2011, while Idaho still allows broad faith-healing exemptions, contributing to continued preventable deaths there.

Conclusion

Today, Evelyn is nine years old. Every year on March 5, her birthday and the anniversary of her twin's death, she visits Ginnifer's grave in the Followers cemetery. She has been baptized in a mainstream church, sees a pediatrician, and is up to date on vaccines—experiences that would have been unthinkable inside the sect.

Marshall Phillips wants Evelyn to choose her own path, including when to marry and whether to attend college. He still lives in Oregon City, where former sect members often ignore him or offer only a nod. Yet the story of Evelyn and Ginnifer remains a powerful example of what can happen when the state decides that a child's right to medical care outweighs a parent's religious objection.