Introduction

In the Minneapolis suburb of Spring Lake Park, Minnesota, a mayoral contest that appeared headed for a narrow victory instead ended in a perfect deadlock. Both candidates finished with exactly 1,401 votes, forcing local election officials to turn to a method rarely seen in modern politics: a random drawing to choose the winner.

What Happened

Election night initially suggested incumbent Bob Nelson had a four-vote lead over challenger Halyn Roth. By the next morning, the margin had disappeared entirely. With the vote count locked at 1,401 apiece, Spring Lake Park's election director, Dan Buchholtz, followed Minnesota procedures for tied races.

Buchholtz and the city attorney chose to draw names from a bag rather than flip a coin or roll dice, calling it the fairest and most objective option. To keep things neutral, both names were typed in the same Arial font, printed on identically sized slips of paper, and placed inside matching toothpick canisters inside a blue city tote bag.

Nearly 100 spectators packed into the council chambers to watch council member Barbara Goodboe-Bisschoff reach into the bag and pull out Nelson's name. The drawing officially gave Nelson the win, but the celebration was short-lived. Just five minutes later, Roth filed for a recount. A panel of election judges is scheduled to hand-count every ballot at the courthouse later this month. If Roth emerges with more votes, he takes office. If the recount produces another tie, Nelson keeps the seat because he won the original drawing.

Why This Matters

Tied elections are more common than many people realize, especially in small municipalities with low voter turnout. Only 2,802 ballots were cast in this mayoral race. Elections law expert Derek Muller of the University of Notre Dame notes that smaller electorates naturally produce more deadlocks, and states handle them in very different ways.

Minnesota is among at least 28 states that use some form of random selection to break legislative ties, and many extend that practice to local races. Other states have settled ties with coin tosses, card games, or drawing straws. In Spring Lake Park, the process drew a crowd and highlighted just how fragile a single vote can be in a local election.

Key Takeaways

  • Bob Nelson and Halyn Roth each received exactly 1,401 votes in the Spring Lake Park mayoral race.
  • A random drawing from a bag selected Nelson as the winner.
  • Roth has requested a recount, which could still change the outcome.
  • Minnesota law allows local officials to choose the tiebreaking method for municipal races.
  • Only about 2,800 people voted in the contest, illustrating how small elections can end in exact ties.

Conclusion

For now, Bob Nelson remains mayor of Spring Lake Park, but his hold on the office is provisional. The upcoming hand recount will determine whether the random draw stands or whether Roth overtakes him. Either way, the race serves as a vivid reminder that in local democracy, every vote counts—and sometimes, luck decides what the ballots cannot.