Introduction
A government-backed energy efficiency programme has left the vast majority of affected households living with defective insulation, with repairs completed on fewer than one in ten impacted properties. Energy Minister Martin McClusky told MPs that more than 90% of homes identified as having faulty external wall insulation are still awaiting corrective work. The revelations have raised fresh questions about oversight of the UK’s home retrofit schemes and the support available to homeowners dealing with damp, mould, and structural damage.
What Happened
According to the minister, 24,600 homes were affected by defective installations under two energy schemes, but only 2,227 have had repairs finished. The programmes in question are ECO4 and the Great British Insulation Scheme (GBIS). ECO4, a £4 billion initiative launched in 2022, funded heat pumps, solar panels, and insulation across more than 300,000 homes before closing in December. GBIS, which operated from 2023 until its recent closure, focused specifically on low-cost insulation to help reduce energy bills.
Audits uncovered widespread poor workmanship as far back as October 2024, yet the backlog of unresolved cases remains substantial. Ofgem administers the schemes, while TrustMark is responsible for auditing installations and identifying defects. The minister acknowledged that the programmes “didn’t have correct oversight” and admitted there had been “failures in the system.”
Why This Matters
For homeowners, the consequences go beyond inconvenience. Ken Palfrey, a 66-year-old retired builder from Birmingham, had external wall insulation fitted through the ECO programme in 2024. He says the work was poorly carried out, damaging his window sills and causing damp and mould to spread across his walls. After two years of emails and complaints, he was told the insulation had to be removed immediately. His case was recently referred to the National Energy Foundation, a charity funded by energy suppliers to remediate homes where the original installer has gone out of business.
Campaigners warn the problem may be far larger than official figures suggest. Fuel Poverty Action estimates that defective upgrades across various government energy schemes could affect as many as 100,000 homes. The group also points out that nearly a third of internal wall insulation is estimated to be defective, yet it was excluded from the government’s “Find and Fix” remediation process.
Key Takeaways
- More than 90% of homes with faulty insulation under government schemes have not been repaired.
- Only 2,227 out of 24,600 affected properties have had remediation work completed.
- The issues primarily involve the ECO4 and Great British Insulation Scheme programmes.
- Ofgem says it was not responsible for assessing installation quality, placing that duty elsewhere in the system.
- The government has stated that affected households should not have to pay for repairs.
- A new Warm Homes Plan is intended to overhaul the system and prevent similar failures.
Conclusion
The scale of unfinished repairs underscores the human cost of rushed retrofit programmes. While officials have promised that homeowners will not bear the financial burden of fixing defective work, thousands remain in limbo, contending with mould, property damage, and the stress of prolonged bureaucracy. As the government prepares to launch its Warm Homes Plan, the test will be whether lessons from ECO4 and GBIS translate into better protection for households in the future.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.