Introduction
The Department of Homeland Security has publicly denied that immigration agents are arresting or deporting American citizens. Officials describe any brief stops as routine questioning that ends immediately once citizenship is confirmed. Yet a yearlong ProPublica investigation has identified more than 500 U.S. citizens who were detained by immigration enforcement agents since the current administration took office. Through photographs and first-person accounts, the project shows the human cost behind the statistics.
What Happened
ProPublica reporters Sarahbeth Maney and Nicole Foy documented cases across the country, with photography by Sarahbeth Maney. The individuals include an elderly car wash owner who was knocked to the ground repeatedly while agents detained his employees, a six-year-old child still experiencing nightmares after agents pointed firearms at him and his siblings, and a high school senior detained when she intervened as officers questioned her autistic younger brother.
One detailed case involves Ana Michelle Ramirez Sanan. In September 2025, she was 17 when agents stopped a car carrying relatives to a court hearing. According to Ramirez Sanan and video reviewed by ProPublica, agents broke vehicle windows, removed her mother, two uncles, and younger brother, and used physical force against her mother. Ramirez Sanan and her brother are both U.S. citizens; her brother is 13 and has autism. She said she was detained after rushing toward her family and pleading for their release. All three were freed the same day, though her mother later received hospital treatment for a concussion, bruising, and nerve damage. DHS has denied that Ramirez Sanan, her mother, or her brother were detained, saying agents used appropriate force to apprehend an uncle facing criminal charges.
Why This Matters
The government's position is that citizens are not being held by immigration agents. ProPublica's findings directly challenge that claim. The documented cases suggest that citizens—including minors and people with disabilities—are being swept into enforcement actions, sometimes with physical force and lasting health consequences. Families describe anxiety, depression, missed school, and missed milestones, such as a father who was held for several days and missed his daughter's third birthday.
Key Takeaways
- ProPublica identified more than 500 U.S. citizens detained by immigration agents since the administration changed.
- DHS publicly denies detaining American citizens and describes any stops as brief and immediately resolved.
- Reported cases include physical injuries, firearm displays near children, and the detention of a teenager and her autistic brother.
- One mother required hospital treatment after an encounter that DHS says never amounted to detention.
- Photographs and interviews show emotional trauma persisting well after release.
Conclusion
The people in ProPublica's photo essay are not abstract figures. They are parents, children, workers, and neighbors who say their citizenship did not protect them from being held by federal immigration agents. As the debate over immigration enforcement continues, their stories raise urgent questions about due process, accountability, and the rights of U.S. citizens on American soil.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.