Introduction

By several headline measures, life in the United States has never looked better on paper. Median household income climbed to $87,460 in 2025, marking the highest point since the Census Bureau began recording the figure in 1967. Average life expectancy also reached a new high of 79 years in 2024.

Yet a larger paycheck does not guarantee a longer life. A Brown University analysis published in the New England Journal of Medicine found that Americans die younger than Europeans at every income level, and that the nation's wealthiest citizens do not outlive the poorest residents of many Western European countries.

What Happened

Sara Machado, a research scientist at Brown's Center for Health System Sustainability, described the result as a plot twist. She noted that even the top wealth quartile in the United States fails to match the health outcomes seen across much of northern and Western Europe.

Researchers followed more than 73,000 adults between the ages of 50 and 85 across the United States and 16 European nations. The project began in 2010 and tracked participants for roughly ten years, drawing on data from the U.S. Health and Retirement Study and Europe's SHARE survey.

The wealthiest individuals in northern and western Europe experienced mortality rates roughly 35 percent lower than their wealthiest American counterparts. In statistical terms, the survival prospects of America's richest quartile matched those of the poorest quartile in nations such as France, Germany, and the Netherlands.

Broadly speaking, mortality across continental Europe ran about 40 percent below U.S. rates during the study window. In southern Europe, the gap was roughly 30 percent.

Machado explained that longevity depends both on a person's position within their own country's wealth distribution and on how that standing compares with peers in other nations.

Why This Matters

U.S. healthcare spending reached an estimated $14,775 per person in 2024—almost $7,000 more per capita than the average for comparable wealthy nations, according to the Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker. Despite that outlay, those countries posted an average life expectancy of 82.7 years, nearly four years beyond the American figure.

Access remains uneven. Census figures indicate that roughly 26.7 million Americans lacked health insurance for the entirety of 2025. Enrollment in ACA marketplace plans also declined, with about 2.6 million fewer people covered in early 2026 compared with the same period in 2025.

Lifestyle factors also contribute. Americans generally follow less healthy diets and lead more sedentary lives, while heart disease and cancer remain the leading causes of death. The researchers pointed out that smoking and rural residence—both associated with worse health—are more prevalent in the United States.

Irene Papanicolas, the study's senior author, highlighted elevated U.S. rates of preventable deaths involving firearms, alcohol, and suicide, along with higher cardiovascular mortality. She also cited a thinner social safety net and a health insurance system more closely tied to employment.

Economic inequality intensifies the problem. The divide between rich and poor is substantially wider in the United States than in Europe, a gap that Peter Mallouk, CEO of Creative Planning, has called unsustainable.

Key Takeaways

  • Even the wealthiest Americans have shorter life expectancies than many Europeans, including lower-income residents of countries such as France, Germany, and the Netherlands.
  • Mortality rates among the wealthiest people in northern and western Europe were about 35 percent lower than among the wealthiest Americans.
  • The United States spends far more per person on healthcare than peer nations, yet those countries enjoy an average life expectancy roughly four years higher.
  • Millions of Americans remain uninsured, and lifestyle factors such as diet, inactivity, and smoking contribute to the gap.
  • Researchers say closing the divide will require understanding systemic factors, not simply increasing healthcare spending.

Conclusion

The CDC attributes recent improvements in American longevity mainly to the pandemic's end, alongside declines in overdose deaths and suicides during 2024. Still, those gains have not erased the disparity with Europe.

Papanicolas, a professor of health services, policy, and practice at Brown, argued that the United States needs a better understanding of the underlying factors driving these differences, especially among similar socioeconomic groups. Machado echoed the sentiment, describing the issue as collective rather than purely individual.

She added that other nations demonstrate better outcomes, suggesting that policymakers and individuals can learn from those examples. The lesson may not be to spend more on healthcare, but to address overlooked factors that could deliver greater benefits than currently realized.