Introduction

During a recent video call with two finance chiefs at a company of 100,000 employees, the conversation turned from pricing to people. The pair had just commissioned a consulting review that found their prices were below their own strategic targets. Closing that gap added a point or two of margin and quickly paid for the project. When asked whether they would apply the same scrutiny to compensation, the room went quiet. One executive finally shrugged and said that everyone assumed their people decisions were sound because nothing appeared to be broken.

That assumption is risky. Compensation is typically one of the largest line items on a corporate budget, yet the individual choices behind it - offers, raises, bonuses, and promotions - often drift from the stated strategy without anyone noticing.

A separate conversation this fall illustrated the shift. An executive who oversees pay at a large company was asked whether they would pursue the chief human resources role after the incumbent announced retirement. The answer was a firm no. They preferred to keep the seat beside the CFO and in front of the board's compensation committee, where the biggest money decisions are made.

What Happened

Internal pay data reviewed by the author's organization shows that roughly 6% of accepted job offers fall outside established salary bands, with one company reaching 16%. At another firm, policy called for hiring near the midpoint of a range, but only 19% of new hires actually landed there. Exceptions are sometimes justified, but they are rarely documented, making them impossible to defend later.

When these deviations are added up, companies are routinely spending 6% to 7% more on compensation than necessary. Much of the waste comes from one-off decisions: the special snowflake executive hire, the counteroffer to retain a valued employee, or a manager's discretionary raise. Individually, each seems reasonable. Collectively, they create a pay strategy built on exceptions rather than design.

The labor market adds another layer of complexity. Overall wage growth and voluntary turnover have flattened, leaving many workers with stagnant pay even as jobs remain plentiful. At the same time, specialized pockets in artificial intelligence, infrastructure, and security are hypercompetitive. AI and machine learning engineers can command base salaries 15% to 20% above comparable technology roles, with senior premiums reaching 30%. Bonuses for AI engineering, cybersecurity, and data architecture can run 20% to 24% of base pay.

There is also a growing pay-compression problem. New hires are frequently entering at or above the salaries of tenured staff. Although three out of four companies say they reward time at the company, regression analysis found that tenure explains none of the typical pay difference. When tenure does show a measurable effect, it works against employees 93.5% of the time, meaning long-tenured workers are often the ones falling behind.

Why This Matters

Compensation leaders sit at the intersection of talent, finance, and legal. Recruiters want competitive offers to win top candidates. Finance wants to avoid unnecessary spending. Legal wants to eliminate pay-equity exposure. New right-to-information and pay-transparency laws mean that unexplained pay gaps are no longer just an internal issue - they are a compliance and reputational risk.

Today, many companies manage pay with blunt instruments: capping budgets, freezing hiring and raises, or resorting to layoffs. The scrutiny is extending beyond HR. Finance departments already face annual audits where they must document where numbers come from and who owns them. A recent BDO survey of 200 finance leaders found that 99% use AI in at least one estimate reviewed by auditors, yet fewer than half can substantiate every result. That same standard is likely to reach compensation decisions soon. Pay leaders who position themselves beside the CFO and before the board's compensation committee want to be in the room that already knows how to answer those questions.

Key Takeaways

  • Individual pay decisions often drift from published salary strategies, costing companies 6% to 7% more than necessary.
  • Pay transparency laws are making undocumented exceptions harder to explain and defend.
  • AI and cybersecurity roles carry significant pay premiums, while tenure explains little to nothing about actual pay differences.
  • Compensation chiefs are increasingly choosing to report alongside finance rather than lead HR, seeking proximity to budget and board decisions.
  • Treating pay like any other major cost center can produce millions in savings and a more defensible talent strategy.

Conclusion

The two finance chiefs on that video call did not hesitate to have their pricing examined. It simply never occurred to them to review pay with the same rigor. That gap is exactly why the best compensation leaders are asking for a seat next to the CFO instead of running HR. Pay is money, and it is time companies started managing it with the same discipline they apply to pricing, revenue, and every other line on the balance sheet.

This article is based on commentary originally published by Fortune and reposted from Pay Dirt, the Substack by Maria Colacurcio. The opinions expressed are solely those of the author.