Introduction
The 2026 holiday shopping season is underway, and retailers are counting on artificial intelligence to help customers find gifts, compare prices, and check out faster. But new research suggests shoppers aren't rushing to embrace these digital helpers. A recent consumer survey paints a picture of caution: only a small fraction of shoppers plan to use AI tools for their holiday purchases, while a majority say they won't use them at all. For brands investing in AI-powered storefronts, the gap between retail enthusiasm and consumer willingness is worth examining.
What Happened
According to a survey of holiday shopping trends, just 9.9% of consumers say they intend to use AI assistants during the 2026 holiday season. By contrast, 52.2% have ruled out using AI for holiday shopping altogether. Adobe's research forecasts that AI-driven traffic to U.S. retail websites could grow by 130% this season, yet that increase remains small compared with traditional advertising and other acquisition channels.
Among shoppers who do use AI tools, product and price comparison stands out as the leading benefit, cited by 27.9% of respondents in a multi-country survey. Other valued features include help building personalized gift lists and locating discount codes. Still, the overall adoption picture suggests AI is far from mainstream in seasonal retail.
Why This Matters
Retailers are pouring resources into AI assistants, but consumer hesitation could limit the return on that investment. Research shows shoppers typically abandon an AI assistant after only three unsuccessful prompts, and nearly a third blame the technology when recommendations miss the mark. Privacy is another flashpoint; customers already worry about how their browsing and purchase data is used, and an AI tool that requests unnecessary personal information can feel intrusive, much like an overly aggressive salesperson.
For businesses, this means that more traffic from AI does not automatically equal more trust or more sales. Clicks generated by an assistant are meaningless if the underlying data is wrong or if the experience frustrates the shopper.
Key Takeaways
- Only 9.9% of surveyed consumers plan to use AI shopping assistants for the 2026 holidays, while 52.2% say they will not use AI at all.
- AI-driven traffic to U.S. retail sites may rise 130% this season, but it still trails traditional marketing channels in scale.
- Shoppers who use AI value it most for comparing products and prices, with 27.9% naming that as the top benefit.
- Most users give up after about three failed prompts, and 32% fault AI for poor recommendations.
- Privacy concerns and irrelevant personal data requests can erode trust quickly.
- Retailers should prioritize accurate inventory, pricing, and return information, and offer a simple path to human support when AI reaches its limits.
Conclusion
The data points to a curious but cautious customer base. AI is technically ready to assist with holiday shopping, but consumer trust still needs to be earned. Retailers that focus on solving real problems—such as cutting through product clutter or surfacing genuine deals—while being transparent about data use are more likely to convert skepticism into repeat usage. The 2026 season offers a chance to demonstrate value without overpromising. Build trust now, and brands will be better positioned when AI adoption eventually moves beyond the early adopters.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.