Introduction
A federal appeals court has invalidated a major spending package from the Biden administration, finding that the measure violated the Constitution because dozens of lawmakers cast votes by proxy rather than appearing in person. The 9-8 decision centers on a $1.7 trillion omnibus bill approved in 2022 and has immediate consequences for a workplace protections law in Texas.
What Happened
The ruling came from a panel of appellate judges who determined that proxy votes cannot be counted toward a quorum under the Constitution's rules for congressional meetings. According to the court's opinion, 226 members of the House voted by proxy on the 2022 spending measure, which passed 225 to 201 with one member present. The majority, writing through Judge Cory Wilson, also said the government failed to prove an emergency existed when Congress adopted proxy voting during the pandemic. A district court had reached the same conclusion in 2022.
The case was brought by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who sought to block enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act in Texas. Friday's decision grants that request, though the opinion states its reach is limited and applies only to that state's enforcement of the law.
Why This Matters
The decision raises questions about other legislation passed with the help of proxy voting, including the broader 2022 spending package that funded federal agencies, directed roughly $45 billion in emergency aid to Ukraine and NATO allies, and allocated about $40 billion for disaster relief. Worker advocacy groups warn the ruling could complicate accommodation claims for pregnant employees in states within the Fifth Circuit. Inimai Chettiar of A Better Balance said employers in those states could cite the opinion when denying accommodations, even though the court described the ruling as limited.
Judge James Graves Jr. dissented, arguing that the majority misread the Quorum Clause and that no lawmaker objected to the absence of a quorum at the time of the vote.
Key Takeaways
- A federal appeals court ruled 9-8 that a $1.7 trillion Biden-era spending bill was unconstitutional.
- The court found that 226 proxy votes did not count toward a constitutional quorum.
- The decision allows Texas to block the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act within the state.
- The opinion claims its reach is limited, applying only to Texas enforcement of the law.
- A dissenting judge argued the Constitution does not require physical presence for a quorum.
- The underlying bill also funded Ukraine aid, NATO support, and disaster relief.
Conclusion
The appeals court's decision marks a significant legal check on how Congress conducted business during the pandemic, at least for the purposes of this specific case. While the justices limited the ruling to Texas enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, the constitutional reasoning could invite further challenges to other laws passed with proxy votes. For now, employers and workers in the Fifth Circuit should watch closely as lower courts apply the opinion.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.