Introduction

My first Oklahoma Drill happened in seventh grade on a sweltering August afternoon at Sequoyah Middle School in Edmond, Oklahoma. It was the first day of pads, and the coach arranged tackling dummies three yards apart to form a narrow chute. A blocker and defender faced off inside while a ball carrier waited behind. When the whistle blew, it became a full-speed collision—and a public test of who had the grit to stand their ground.

The rest of the team formed a circle around the action, turning the practice field into something that resembled an impromptu street fight. For nearly an hour, thirteen-year-olds took turns stepping into the arena while classmates cheered or groaned at every heavy hit. I waited nervously, hoping I wouldn't embarrass myself or get hurt. When my turn arrived, I was assigned to defend against a much larger opponent. He ran straight through me, helmets cracked, and I landed on my back wondering if I was seriously injured. I wasn't, but the lesson stuck: football demanded toughness, and proving it meant taking a hit in front of everyone.

What Happened

The drill traces back to Bud Wilkinson, who became head coach at the University of Oklahoma in 1947. Wilkinson introduced a 5-2 defensive scheme that required interior linemen to control two gaps at once, beating blockers in tight spaces before making tackles. He also wanted a way to identify players with aggression and toughness, drawing on lessons from the Navy's V-5 pre-flight program, which used boxing and wrestling to screen cadets.

The Oklahoma Drill served as both a teaching tool and a sorting mechanism. The Sooners went on to win 47 consecutive games from 1953 to 1957, a college football record that still stands. As the program's reputation grew, the drill spread to other colleges, the NFL, and eventually down to high school and youth teams. Coaches such as Vince Lombardi, Bill Belichick, and Barry Switzer praised it as a measure of manhood and a quick way to evaluate a player's willingness to hit.

Over time, however, the risks became impossible to ignore. The drill's design forces straight-line, high-speed collisions, including helmet-to-helmet contact. Research has linked repeated head impacts—even those that do not cause concussions—to chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a degenerative brain condition. High-profile injuries and deaths connected to the drill added pressure to eliminate it. The NFL prohibited it in 2019, and the NCAA followed in 2021. USA Football now advises youth and high school programs to drop it as well.

Many coaches have replaced it with rugby-style tackling exercises that emphasize shoulder contact and keeping the head out of the way. Still, the Oklahoma Drill survives in corners of social media, where videos show young people running the drill without pads on beaches and in amateur competitions with weight classes and rankings.

Why This Matters

Eliminating the Oklahoma Drill was almost certainly the right decision from a health and safety standpoint. Yet its decline touches on a deeper cultural question. Across history and around the world, rites of passage have been used to instill bravery, resilience, and the ability to endure discomfort in young men. Many of these traditions seem unnecessarily dangerous, but they answer a powerful desire to test and prove oneself.

Modern society often wants young men to face meaningful challenges without real risk or pain. The problem is that significance and safety tend to move in opposite directions. If you make an experience completely safe, it often loses its transformative power. The military's BUD/S training, for example, would not carry the same weight if no one ever faced serious danger. We have removed a risky ritual like the Oklahoma Drill, but we have not yet figured out what should take its place.

Key Takeaways

  • Bud Wilkinson created the Oklahoma Drill at the University of Oklahoma in the late 1940s to teach gap control and identify aggressive players.
  • The drill became widely popular after Oklahoma's 47-game winning streak and was adopted by the NFL, colleges, high schools, and youth leagues.
  • Coaches viewed it as a test of toughness and manhood, not just a football exercise.
  • Concerns over CTE and repeated head trauma led the NFL to ban the drill in 2019 and the NCAA to ban it in 2021.
  • USA Football recommends that youth and high school teams stop using it, though informal versions still appear online and in amateur events.
  • The drill's disappearance highlights a broader dilemma: how to create meaningful rites of passage for young men without exposing them to unnecessary physical danger.

Conclusion

I hated the Oklahoma Drill when I was thirteen, and I would not want my own child subjected to it today. Still, I recognize that it taught me something difficult to replicate in a completely safe environment: that taking a hit, whether physical or psychological, is often less devastating than we imagine. Young people need opportunities to demonstrate courage and resilience, but those opportunities do not have to come with a high risk of brain injury.

The challenge ahead is finding a balance. We need challenges that matter enough to change a person, without being so dangerous that they become reckless. Football has moved on from the Oklahoma Drill, but the question of how to build character in a safer world remains unanswered.