Introduction

Walk through an airport, order a package, or browse grocery shelves and you will see promises stamped on products and tickets: carbon neutral, net zero, climate friendly. Those claims rest on a shared idea—that greenhouse gas pollution from burning fossil fuels can simply be captured and buried underground. But a fresh investigation into the computer models driving global climate policy suggests that confidence may be misplaced.

What Happened

Reporters examined how the world came to depend so heavily on carbon capture and storage, known as CCS. The technology aims to trap carbon dioxide before it reaches the atmosphere and pump it deep underground. Despite decades of development, only a dozen large-scale geologic storage projects have ever been built, and at least seven have underperformed or failed. In the most recent year for which data was reviewed, the amount of CO2 buried worldwide was less than what a single large power plant emits annually.

The investigation also found that major climate models used by negotiators and policymakers assume CCS will work at a scale that would rival today’s entire global oil industry within a few decades. Those assumptions appear at the center of discussions at the United Nations climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, where nations negotiate commitments to limit warming.

Why This Matters

If the models are wrong, the consequences could be severe. Simulations that guide decisions about retiring coal plants or electrifying transportation could produce faulty roadmaps, leaving coastal cities and vulnerable communities exposed to warming they were supposed to avoid. Because many corporate and national climate pledges treat carbon capture as a guaranteed offset, a shortfall in real-world CCS performance could mean those pledges fail to deliver actual emissions reductions.

Key Takeaways

  • Only 12 large-scale carbon storage projects have been built in roughly 30 years, and at least seven have underperformed or failed.
  • Real-world capture rates are far lower than the 90%-plus success rates assumed by some influential climate models.
  • Major projects, including Chevron’s Gorgon plant in Australia, have struggled with clogged wells, pressure spikes, and unintended CO2 releases.
  • Models generally do not account for the risk of stored carbon leaking back into the atmosphere over time.
  • Underground storage capacity may be far more limited than older United Nations reports suggested.
  • Real-world costs for carbon capture have risen, even though models project they will become cheaper.

Conclusion

Carbon capture may still have a role in a broader climate strategy, but treating it as a proven, scalable solution is risky. Policymakers, companies, and the public should scrutinize the assumptions behind net zero claims and demand greater transparency from the modelers whose simulations shape the planet’s future. Until the technology proves itself at scale, leaning on it as a primary climate solution could delay more reliable emissions cuts.