Introduction
On November 19, the presidents of China, Russia, and the United States are scheduled to sit down for their first formal trilateral meeting. The gathering will take place in Shenzhen on the margins of the annual Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. Some observers have already labeled the event historic, while others in Moscow have gone further, describing it as a potential "new Yalta" capable of redrawing the world into spheres of influence. A closer look at the three leaders’ competing agendas suggests that such a grand bargain is far from realistic.
What Happened
The meeting was proposed by Russian President Vladimir Putin during an October phone call with U.S. President Donald Trump. It will bring together Xi Jinping, Putin, and Trump in Shenzhen, marking the first time the three nations have held formal trilateral talks. In Russian circles, the summit is being compared to the 1945 Yalta Conference, where Britain, the Soviet Union, and the United States divided the postwar world after defeating a common enemy. Today’s context is different: the three powers are on opposing sides of multiple disputes and hold sharply different visions for international order.
Why This Matters
Although Beijing, Moscow, and Washington all endorse the idea of a multipolar world, they define it in incompatible ways. Russia wants recognition as a leading pole in Eurasia. The United States seeks to remain the preeminent global power. China is focused on attracting countries in the Global South away from U.S. leadership. In practice, Washington and Beijing appear to be moving toward a bipolar arrangement—what Trump has called a "G2"—leaving Russia with little ability to shape the outcome.
The technological gap is equally stark. The United States and China lead in semiconductors, artificial intelligence, space exploration, robotics, and biotechnology. Russia, by contrast, has fallen behind by decades and has pursued what the author describes as a path of archaisation. On security, Trump has raised nuclear disarmament, a topic that holds little appeal for China given its smaller arsenal and for Russia given its reliance on nuclear weapons for great-power status. Putin reportedly wants to discuss a settlement in Ukraine without Kyiv or European leaders present, but his maximalist demands and vision for a revised European order would violate principles of sovereignty and international law—positions Beijing is unlikely to endorse.
Key Takeaways
- China, Russia, and the United States will hold their first formal trilateral summit in Shenzhen on November 19, on the sidelines of APEC.
- The idea of a "new Yalta" dividing the world into spheres of influence is largely wishful thinking, given the leaders’ divergent goals.
- Moscow, Washington, and Beijing disagree on what multipolarity means, with the U.S. and China appearing to favor a bipolar "G2" dynamic.
- Russia lags far behind the U.S. and China in critical technologies, from AI to semiconductors.
- Disagreements over nuclear arms and a Ukraine settlement without Ukrainian or European participation further limit the summit’s potential.
- For Xi Jinping, hosting the two other leaders is primarily a symbolic affirmation of China’s global standing.
Conclusion
Rather than producing a new world order, the summit is likely to result in, at most, a general declaration of cooperation. Xi Jinping may view the event as a foreign-policy triumph and a recognition of China’s rise from postwar dependence on the Soviet Union to a leadership role in global manufacturing and technology. Yet the three leaders represent what the author calls an outgoing generation, shaped more by nostalgia and old rivalries than by a shared vision for the future. Any lasting trilateral format may persist, but it is unlikely to resolve the world’s most pressing problems. Eventually, a new generation of policymakers will replace them.
The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the publication’s editorial stance.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.