Introduction

The aftermath of the 2026 midterm elections has triggered a sharp escalation in the fight over who gets to regulate prediction markets. While Democrats gained control of Congress and several governorships, much of the immediate enforcement activity has come from Republican-led states. At the center of the conflict is Kalshi, a major prediction marketplace now contending with criminal charges, civil lawsuits, and conflicting court rulings across the country.

What Happened

Shortly after Election Day, Louisiana's attorney general moved to block multiple prediction exchanges from operating in the state, and a judge issued a temporary restraining order against the companies on November 12. The same week, the U.S. Senate passed a bipartisan measure prohibiting CFTC-registered platforms from offering contracts tied to terrorism, assassination, war, military operations, or an individual's death.

Utah has taken an especially aggressive approach. In late October, the state's attorney general filed 14 criminal charges against Kalshi and its founders, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, alleging violations of state gambling law. The founders are scheduled to appear in Utah's Third District Court in early December. A separate civil complaint also named institutional market maker Susquehanna International Group alongside Kalshi.

Federal regulators are pushing back. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission has sued Louisiana and Arkansas, arguing that it holds exclusive authority over prediction markets. The agency says it has now taken legal action against a dozen states. Meanwhile, the CFTC has placed holds on certain event contracts, including those tied to statements by President Donald Trump, citing concerns about manipulation in so-called "mention" markets.

On the judicial front, the Fourth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Maryland can enforce its gambling laws against Kalshi. The decision was fractured, with three separate opinions from the two-judge majority. Across the circuit courts, prediction platforms have recorded three losses and one win, leaving the ultimate question of state versus federal authority likely headed to the Supreme Court.

Why This Matters

The regulatory tug-of-war has real consequences for an industry worth billions. If states can enforce their own gambling laws against prediction market operators, companies like Kalshi may face a patchwork of restrictions that vary by jurisdiction. The CFTC, by contrast, wants a single national standard under its supervision.

The political dimension adds another layer of complexity. Kalshi ended its advisory relationship with Donald Trump Jr. after his venture firm disclosed an investment in rival Polymarket. Democratic lawmakers have also signaled plans to scrutinize ties between prediction platforms and the Trump family, while some members of Congress have called for an outright ban on sports-related prediction contracts.

Key Takeaways

  • The Senate passed a bipartisan bill banning certain high-risk event contracts, including those involving war, terrorism, or death.
  • Utah filed criminal charges against Kalshi and its founders, while Louisiana secured a temporary restraining order against prediction exchanges.
  • The CFTC has sued 12 states to defend what it describes as its exclusive regulatory jurisdiction.
  • A divided Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals allowed Maryland to apply its gambling law to Kalshi.
  • Kalshi severed ties with Donald Trump Jr. over his firm's stake in competitor Polymarket.
  • Legal experts expect the U.S. Supreme Court to ultimately resolve the state-federal jurisdictional dispute.

Conclusion

Prediction markets are entering a pivotal legal chapter. With criminal prosecutions, civil injunctions, and competing federal lawsuits all in motion, the industry faces uncertainty about where it can operate and under whose rules. Until the Supreme Court or Congress provides clarity, platforms such as Kalshi will likely continue operating in a fragmented and hostile legal environment.

Disclosure: CNBC and Kalshi maintain a commercial relationship that includes customer acquisition and a minority investment.